We Compared 6 of the Most Searched Tallow Balm Brands, Label by Label
The Tallowed Truth, Holy Cow, Based Supplies, Evil Goods, Neptune and Serabel all sell a tallow and honey balm. Here is what each brand prints about its jar, side by side, so you can compare before you buy.
The short version
- Our pick: Serabel Whipped Tallow & Honey Balm. Five named ingredients, no fragrance, no preservatives, grass-fed and grass-finished tallow.
- Closest on the label: Holy Cow (Herd House) and The Tallowed Truth, both in their unscented versions.
- Lowest price per jar: Neptune and Based Supplies on their multi-jar deals, but both standard jars are scented. Evil Goods adds a marigold extract.
If you searched for a specific tallow brand, you are probably comparing. That is the right instinct: these balms look alike in photos, and the differences are on the label, in the scent, and in the price per jar.
We read each brand's own product page on the same day and put the facts side by side. The ranking rule is below; it applies to our pick too.
A balm moisturizes. It is a cosmetic, not a treatment for any skin condition. If you have a persistent skin problem, see a dermatologist.
Looking for Terra Lotus?
When we checked on November 12, 2026, Terra Lotus's store showed “This store is unavailable”, so we could not verify its current ingredients or price and left it out of this comparison. Its unscented balm was a four-ingredient tallow, olive oil, beeswax and honey jar when we last saw it.
How we ranked them
- Is every ingredient named? A full list ranks above a list that ends in an unnamed “blend”.
- Is the standard jar free of added scent? Fragrance and essential oils are the usual reason a simple balm does not suit sensitive skin. A brand that sells an unscented option gets credit for it.
- Any extras beyond the basics? Botanical extracts, water, emulsifiers or preservatives. A jar with none ranks above a jar with one.
- How is the tallow described? “Grass-fed and grass-finished” ranks above “grass-fed” alone.
- Price per jar, on each brand's best listed offer, breaks a tie on the first four.
Guarantees are shown for information, in each brand's own words, and are not part of the ranking. This is a label comparison: we did not test the balms on skin or in a lab. The order follows the rule above; it is still our editorial opinion, and we have a financial interest in the top pick.
The 6 jars, side by side
| Product | Ingredients as printed | Added scent | Extras | Tallow, as worded | One jar | Guarantee (not ranked) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Serabel Our pick |
5: grass-fed beef tallow, raw honey, cold-pressed olive oil, beeswax, vitamin E (tocopherol) | None listed. Serabel says: “no synthetic fragrance” | None. “No preservatives”, per the brand | “grass-fed, grass-finished tallow” on the offer page; “100% Grass-Fed Tallow” on the jar | $49.99 for 2 jars on the Buy 1, Get 1 Free subscription offer ($25.00 a jar); $79.99 for 4 jars ($20.00 a jar) | “90-day money-back guarantee” |
| Holy Cow / Herd House | Grass-fed and finished beef tallow, organic extra virgin olive oil, organic raw honey, organic beeswax; scented versions add lavender, frankincense or rose essential oils | Unscented option; lavender, frankincense and rose versions | None in the unscented jar | “Regenerative 100% Grass-Fed & Finished Beef Tallow” | $29.00 (2 oz); 10% off on subscription | None stated on the product page |
| The Tallowed Truth | Grass-fed tallow, organic cold-pressed olive oil, beeswax, raw honey, frankincense essential oil | Standard jar: honey and frankincense; an unscented F-Balm is sold | None in the unscented jar; frankincense oil in the standard one | “100% Grass-Fed, Grass-Finished Beef Tallow” | CAD $49.00 one-time; CAD $39.20 on subscription | “30-Day Money-Back Guarantee” |
| Evil Goods | Grass-fed, grass-finished tallow, manuka honey (MGO 360+, in some versions), cold-pressed olive oil, organic vitamin E, pot marigold extract | Unscented option; four scented versions (lavender, citrus, sandalwood, santal vanilla) | One: pot marigold (calendula) extract | “grass-fed, grass-finished beef tallow” | $34.99 one-time; $26.24 first order on subscription | “30-Day Money Back Guarantee” |
| Based Supplies | Organic grass-fed and grass-finished beef tallow (kidney suet), organic raw honey, organic beeswax, cold-pressed organic olive oil, plus sandalwood, neroli, Scots pine and rose essential oils | Yes in the standard jar, diluted to under 1% per the brand. A no-essential-oil jar is sold separately | Four essential oils in the standard jar | “grass-fed and grass-finished” kidney suet | $30.00 (2 oz); bundles: buy 3, get 2 free for $90 | “30-day money-back guarantee” |
| Neptune | “Grass Fed Beef Tallow, Olive Oil, Honey, Beeswax, Essential Oil Blend” (oils not named) | Yes, an unnamed essential oil blend | An unnamed essential oil blend | “Grass Fed & Finished Tallow” | $33.00; limited-time deals such as buy 3, get 3 for $99 | “60-Day Satisfaction Guarantee” |
Sources: tryserabel offer page and jar label; herdhouse.shop product page (holycowtallow.com redirects there); thetallowedtruth.com product page; evilgoods.com product page; basedsupplies.com product page and ingredient image; neptunehealthco.com product page. Read on each brand's own website on November 12, 2026. Guarantee wording is quoted from each product or offer page; the conditions are in each brand's refund policy. Brands change prices and formulas, so confirm on their sites before you buy.
The six jars, ranked
Serabel Whipped Tallow & Honey Balm
Best overall: five named ingredients, no added scent, no extras, grass-fed and grass-finished tallow
Serabel prints a five-item ingredient list and nothing else: grass-fed beef tallow, raw honey, cold-pressed olive oil, beeswax and vitamin E. The brand states “no preservatives, no synthetic fragrance”, which is the first thing to look for if scented products tend to bother your skin.
The balm is whipped, so it comes out of the jar soft instead of as a hard block. Serabel's directions: a pea-sized amount is enough for the whole face, warmed and massaged in, with a little more on dry patches, hands, elbows “or anywhere that cracks in cold weather”. Those are the brand's statements; we did not test them.
What is in the jar
- Beef tallow grass-fed
- Honey raw
- Olive oil cold-pressed
- Beeswax
- Tocopherol vitamin E
What we like
- Every ingredient named, five in total
- No fragrance or essential oils on the list
- No preservatives, water or emulsifiers
- Tallow described as grass-fed and grass-finished
- Whipped texture, 2 oz jar
- $20 to $25 a jar on the current offer
What to know
- The offer price is a subscription; refills every four weeks
- Raw honey, not manuka
- Not vegan (tallow, honey, beeswax)
- Sold online only
What customers say on Serabel's offer page
“I’ve tried so many things — luxury serums, drugstore creams, dermatologist samples — but this is the first time my skin actually held onto moisture. I’m not fighting tightness all day anymore.”Tina S. · Verified Customer
“That’s the biggest change — I finally feel like my face can breathe after cleansing. No more counting down the minutes until I can put cream on.”Melissa R. · Verified Customer
“No more flaking around my nose and my face doesn’t feel like cardboard after washing. I’m obsessed!”Shanice C. · Verified Customer
“I didn’t just want to look better — I wanted to trust my own skin again. This balm helped me stop the cycle of buying and quitting.”Jo C. · Verified Customer
Photos from Serabel's store.
Holy Cow Tallow (now Herd House) Whipped Tallow Balm
Clean whipped balm from a small brand
Holy Cow Tallow's site now redirects to Herd House, which sells the same whipped balm. The unscented 2 oz jar lists regenerative grass-fed and finished beef tallow, organic extra virgin olive oil, organic raw honey and organic beeswax. One jar is $29.00.
On the label it is close to our pick: named ingredients, an unscented option, no extras and grass-fed and finished tallow. It places behind Serabel on price per jar ($29.00, or about $26 with its 10% subscription discount, against $20 to $25 on Serabel's offer). It is a small brand with 24 reviews on its page, and we found no guarantee stated.
What we like
- Short, fully named list
- Unscented option
- Whipped texture, 2 oz jar
What to know
- No guarantee stated on the product page
- Only 24 reviews on its page
- Name changed from Holy Cow Tallow to Herd House
The Tallowed Truth F-Balm
Grass-fed and grass-finished, with an unscented option
A Canadian brand with a big following: its page shows 4.67 stars from 27,418 reviews. The standard F-Balm lists grass-fed tallow, organic cold-pressed olive oil, beeswax, raw honey and frankincense essential oil, in a 2 oz jar, and describes the tallow as “100% grass-fed, grass-finished”.
On our label rule its unscented version matches our pick on every step: all ingredients named, no added scent, no extras, grass-fed and grass-finished. It places behind our pick on the tie-breaker, price per jar: CAD $49.00 one-time or CAD $39.20 on subscription, against $20 to $25 a jar on Serabel's current offer. The standard jar is scented with frankincense, so pick unscented if scent bothers your skin.
What we like
- Every ingredient named
- Unscented version available
- Grass-fed and grass-finished tallow
- Large number of reviews
What to know
- Standard jar contains frankincense essential oil
- Priced in Canadian dollars
- Higher price per jar than our pick's current offer
Evil Goods Whipped Tallow & Manuka Honey Moisturizer
The whipped option with manuka honey
Also whipped, with every ingredient named: grass-fed, grass-finished tallow, cold-pressed olive oil, organic vitamin E and pot marigold extract, with MGO 360+ manuka honey in some versions. If manuka honey matters to you, this is the closest match to our pick in format. Its page shows 4.51 stars from 1,515 reviews.
It ranks behind our pick because of one extra on the list: pot marigold (calendula) extract, a botanical some people with plant sensitivities prefer to avoid. One jar is $34.99 one-time, or $26.24 for the first order on its subscription.
What we like
- Five named ingredients, manuka honey
- Whipped texture
- Unscented option
What to know
- Contains pot marigold (calendula) extract
- Manuka honey only in some versions
- Jar size not shown in the product text
Based Supplies Tallow & Honey Balm
Well known, scented by default
One of the names people search for in this category, with a 2 oz jar at $30.00 and multi-jar bundles. The list reads organic grass-fed and grass-finished beef tallow (kidney suet), organic raw honey, organic beeswax and cold-pressed organic olive oil, scented with sandalwood, neroli, Scots pine and rose essential oils. Its page shows 4.96 stars from 4,327 reviews.
Every oil is named, and the brand says they make up under 1%. It ranks lower because the standard jar is scented. If you want this brand without the oils, it sells a separate no-essential-oil balm.
What we like
- All ingredients named, including each essential oil
- $30.00 for a 2 oz jar
- A no-essential-oil version exists
What to know
- Standard jar contains four essential oils
- Unscented jar is a separate product
- No vitamin E on the list
Neptune Grass Fed Tallow & Honey Balm
Manuka honey, but an unnamed oil blend
Neptune highlights grass-fed and finished tallow, manuka honey (UMF 10+) and Moroccan olive oil, in a 2 oz jar at $33.00, with multi-jar deals running. Its page shows 4.3 stars from 2,357 reviews.
It sits lower on our rule for one checkable reason: the ingredient list ends with “Essential Oil Blend” and does not name the oils, even though a banner on the same site says “Unscented”.
What we like
- Manuka honey UMF 10+ per the product page
- 2 oz jar, size printed
- Tallow described as grass-fed and finished
What to know
- Essential oil blend not itemized
- Standard jar is scented
How much to use, and how
- Warm it up. Scoop a pea-sized amount and warm it between your fingertips.
- Massage it in. On clean skin, face first, then any dry patches.
- Give it a minute. Before makeup, let it settle. If it feels heavy, use less next time.
Steps 1 and 2 follow Serabel's directions. Step 3 is our own tip.
Why Serabel took the top spot
On the rule above, three jars clear all four label steps in their unscented versions: Serabel, Holy Cow (Herd House) and The Tallowed Truth. The tie-breaker is price per jar: $20 to $25 on Serabel's current offer, about $26 on Herd House's subscription, and CAD $39.20 on Tallowed Truth's. Serabel also ships unscented by default, has the most detailed ingredient list of the three and a 90-day guarantee. The margins are narrow and you can check every one of them on the brands' own sites.
A buying checklist that works for any tallow balm
- Read the full ingredient list, not the front of the jar. Look for unnamed “blends” and fragrance.
- Check the jar size in ounces before comparing prices.
- Open the refund policy before you order; a guarantee line is a summary.
- If the price is a subscription price, check when the next charge happens and how to cancel.
- Be wary of any balm that promises to fix a skin condition. A moisturizer moisturizes.
Questions readers ask
Which tallow balm brand is the cleanest?
On the label, the unscented versions of Serabel, Holy Cow (Herd House) and The Tallowed Truth are the shortest lists with no added scent or extras. Serabel ships unscented by default.
Is Holy Cow Tallow the same as Herd House?
holycowtallow.com now redirects to Herd House, and the brand's replies to reviews are signed by the Holy Cow Tallow team.
Why is Based Supplies ranked lower?
Its standard jar is scented with four essential oils. The brand sells a separate no-essential-oil balm.
Is the price a subscription?
Yes. Serabel's current Buy 1, Get 1 Free offer is a subscription: the page says refills ship every four weeks. Check the refill amount and how to cancel at checkout.
What does the 90-day guarantee cover?
Serabel's page says: “Your order is protected by our 90-day money-back guarantee.” The conditions are in its refund policy; read it before ordering.
Is a tallow balm a medical treatment?
No. These are cosmetic moisturizers. They are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease or skin condition.
Our pick, in one box
Serabel Whipped Tallow & Honey Balm
Five named ingredients, no added fragrance, no extras, 2 oz jar. Currently Buy 1, Get 1 Free: $49.99 for 2 jars on subscription, $79.99 for 4. 90-day money-back guarantee, per the offer page.